Saturday, February 2, 2019

REITs Part II: Interest Rates



This is the second part of my analyses of REITs. Refer to Part 1 here.

The first part deals with the components of a dividend yield, where I mentioned that the risk-free rate sets the base for a REIT's dividend yield. In this post, I will focus on this component, as it is a long term driver of REIT yields as a sector.

Brief history of interest rates. Broadly speaking, as REITs trade like junk/high yield bonds, changes in government bond yields generally drive dividend yields. Institutional investors like pension funds, insurance firms, asset management companies and even central banks, tend to perceive REITs relative to government and corporate bond yields, especially since the Global Financial Crisis of 2009. Recall that at the height of the financial crisis, the Federal Reserve brought its policy rate to an unprecedented zero percent. Even with that, lending activity remained depressed and total loans in the system fell as US households deleveraged after the property bubble burst.

While short term interest rates were close to zero, longer-term interest rates remained somewhat higher. This led the Federal Reserve to embark on a series of government bond buying sprees. This entailed the central bank going into the government bond market, and buying bonds using what was essentially digital money created out of thin air. This was known as the Quantitative Easing (QE) program.

The net result of several rounds of QE led to lower bond yields and a lot more cash in the financial system. Note that while the official interest rate (Fed Fund Rate) and the US 2-year government bond was at 0%, the 10-year and 30-year government bond yields declined steadily between 2010 and 2015. This was a direct consequence of the Federal Reserve purchasing more than USD 2 trillion of US Government bonds under its Quantitative Easing program. (technical way of saying that the Federal Reserve 'printed' USD 2 trillion and bought government bonds). Naturally, by pushing down the 10 and 30-year government bond yields, this results in lower borrowing costs for companies that are issuing long-tenure bonds and even individuals seeking mortgages.


If you thought low bond yields are already bad enough, other major economies of the developed world, namely Europe and Japan took this unconventional monetary policy to new heights, by pushing interest rates and government bond yields into negative territory. The goal of this radical monetary policy was to lower borrowing costs so as to stimulate economic activity, but the side effect was inflation of asset prices globally (primary beneficiaries were stocks and real estate).

In case you were wondering, a bond with a negative yield does not mean a negative coupon. It just means that the bondholder will eventually receive his principal upon bond maturity that is lower than his initial purchase price, with the coupons collected insufficient to compensate for that difference.

How does this tie into REITs? Institutional investors drive global markets. They run the gamut from hedge funds, family offices, banks, treasury desks of large corporations, to central banks and sovereign wealth funds. They all have varying degrees of risk appetites and investment horizons, but of interest to us are what are known as 'Liability Driven Investors' (LDIs). LDIs are basically investors that make investment decisions with the primary goal of meeting future liabilities. Classic examples of LDIs are pension funds and insurance firms, who must invest not with the primary goal of short term profits, but must generate returns to meet expected payouts in the present as well as remain solvent for the distant future.

Think about your own personal insurance policies (perhaps life, or even medical insurance) from the perspective of your insurer. Your insurance firm must be able to generate sufficient returns from its portfolio not just to meet a claim anytime between the present and decades from now, but generate profits to satisfy its own shareholders at the same time. As such, LDIs typically rely on stable but low volatility investments to meet its ongoing obligations. In the pre-crisis era, bonds constituted the bulk of an LDI's portfolio. However, zero/negative interest rates and very low bond yields have made traditional LDI asset allocation very unsuitable for obvious reasons. This has led to LDIs allocating more assets to stocks in a bid to generate better returns, and REITs have been a natural alternative to bonds owing to their relatively stable dividend yields. It is this relationship that has transformed REITs into a quasi-junk bond investment class.

The relationship between the government bond yield and REITs is more apparent in the large-cap and liquid REITs as they are most likely to be held by institutions as opposed to their counterparts that are less liquid or of smaller REITs. The chart below shows the dividend yield of CapitaLand Malls Trust (CT) and CapitaLand Commercial Trust (CCT), as compared against the yield of a 5-year Singapore Government Bond (SGB). While not perfect, there is a reasonably strong correlation between the movement of dividend yields and bond yields. For the mathematically inclined, the correlation factor between these REITs and the 5-year SGB is between 0.6-0.7. 
From the chart above, we can see that the two REITs trade at a fairly constant premium to the SGB, in what is the risk-premium that investors receive for taking on risks as described in Part 1. Here, we can see with clarity that movements in the underlying bond yields are a causative factor behind changes in the REITs' dividend yields. Bearing in mind that dividend yields are a function of DPU dividend by a REIT's unit price, dividend yields can only respond to a change in SGB yields through a change in unit price. Therefore, if bond yields were to rise sharply suddenly, dividend yields would follow suit, but only through a fall in unit price. 

It is through this mechanism that we can see why REITs tend to perform poorly in periods of rising bond yields, despite the broader stock market faring well. Likewise, falling bond yields globally since late 2018 has translated in a broad based REIT rally, simply because REIT dividend yields are falling, tracking the underlying fall in bond yields. 

So when do REITs generally perform well? The sweet spot where most REITs outperform or perform as well as regular stocks is in a 'goldilocks-like' situation of modest economic growth. In this climate of lukewarm growth and business sentiments, central banks tend to keep interest rates low and monetary conditions easy. On the other hand, strong economic growth usually means higher interest rates, such as the US in 2017-18, which led to bond yields rising and ultimately hurt REITs globally. On the other hand, recessionary economic conditions will also hurt REITs in general, as vacancy rates can be expected to rise and rental rates fall (as how certain industrial REITs were impacted in the aftermath of the crude oil price plunge in 2014). REITs with a more resilient lease structure (longer leases, defensive sectors such as healthcare) will generally perform better in this environment as bond yields will fall.

So far I have only touched on the market aspect of dividend yields and bond yields/interest rates. Bond yields also affect a REIT's fundamentals in terms of its interest expense, since all REITs are leveraged. Rising interest rates will result in lower DPU, holding all else constant. Since REITs have the ability to take out bank loans or issue bonds, rising interest rates and bond yields will generally affect their interest expense.

Also, interest rates feature heavily in the calculus of acquiring new assets. The REIT manager will have to factor in the prevailing cost of debt (interest cost) plus cost of equity, if the REIT has to raise fresh equity. Should the cost of debt and/or cost of equity be higher relative to the yield of the asset-that-is-to-be-acquired, the deal will end up to be DPU dilutive. Therefore, interest rates can and do impact the viability of new assets. Generally, a lower interest rate makes an acquisition more viable. Investors familiar with the S-REIT space would have taken note that S-REITs have been exploring aggressively in Europe over the last few years. It is also no coincidence that interest rates in the Eurozone are very low, making it viable for REIT managers to borrow in EUR and purchase yield-accretive assets there.

Therefore REITs are generally very sensitive to interest rates (more so than stocks in general) as rising interest rates will have a two-fold effect:

  1. Market effect - rising bond yields means that the REIT's dividend yields are pressured to rise (higher dividend yield implies lower REIT price)
  2. Fundamental effect - rising bond yields translates directly into higher interest expense (lower DPU). A lower DPU compounds the market effect described above, since if dividend yields are rising, and DPU is falling, the unit price must fall by a larger quantum. 
A simple example to demonstrate this is with a hypothetical REIT with a DPU of 6 cents and a unit price of $1.00. This translates into a dividend yield of 6.0%. Let us assume that interest rates were to rise by 0.50%, and that this hypothetical REIT's market dividend yield follows suit. The outcome are as the following:

 

Here, we can see how rising interest rates are a double-whammy for REITs. Conversely, in the same example, if interest rates were to fall by 0.50% instead, the unit price would rise to $1.09 just accounting for the immediate market effect. A higher DPU of 6.5 cents, due to lower interest expense would work out to a unit price of $1.18.



Please note that the calculations above are purely hypothetical as the Fundamental Effect depends on the REIT's debt profile. If the REIT has a debt profile of long-term fixed rate loans or bonds, the interest costs will not be impacted by short term fluctuations in interest rates. In this case, the timing of when the REIT has to roll over its debt is critical. On the other hand, a REIT with a larger exposure to floating interest rates will see greater variability in its interest expense. Clearly, the examples above assumes that the REIT's debts consist of floating rate loans and bonds (perhaps tied to the SIBOR)

Summary
Interest rates and bond yields are the tide that lifts and lowers the REITs as a sector. A REIT investor ignores the broader environment of interest rates, to the peril of his portfolio. Knowing this will help you to understand why REITs tend to sell-off even if the broader stock market is not. Or why REITs seem to participate in a stock rally at times, and at other times, remain on the sidelines.
Share:

19 comments:

  1. Hello, everyone
    My name is Josephine jumawan caballo, i live in orion bataan, phillipine. I would like to thank good mother karina roland for helping me got a good loan after I experienced fake online borrowing loans that tricked me to get money without giving a loan, I have needed a loan for 2 years ago to start my own business in the city of orion bataan where I lived and I fell into the hands of a fake company in dubai that deceived me and did not offer me a loan. and I was very Frustrasted because I lost all my money to a fake company in dubai, because I owed my bank and my friends and I had nothing to run, on that very faithful day my friend called susan Ramirez after reading her testimony about how he got a loan from Mrs. karina roland, so I was forced to contact Susan Ramirez and she told me and convinced me to contact Mrs. KARINA ROLAND LOAN COMPANY that she was a good mother and I was forced to put courage and I contacted Mrs. karina roland and I were surprised by my loan that was processed and passed and within 6 hours my loan was transferred to my account and I was very surprised that this was a miracle and I had to give information about the good work of Mrs. KARINA ROLAND so I advise everyone who needs a loan to contact e-mail Mrs. KARINA ROLAND at (karinarolandloancompany@gmail.com) or whatsapp only +1(312)8721-592 and I guarantee you that you will give information as I have done and you can also contact me for further information about Mrs.KARINA ROLAND my email: (josephinejumawancaballo@gmail.com) may God continue to bless and love karina roland' mother to change my financial life.

    ReplyDelete
  2. My name is SHARON LOGAN, I am from Washington, D.C. U.S.A, I want to use this media to write to people in the internet who is in need of a real loan, that if you need a loan without getting cheated apply from karina roland loan company is the right company to apply from i am a teacher i was cheated 2 time by a fake company who clam to be lenders but at end up be scammed, but now i no longer worry because karina ronad has already helped me so if you need an urgent loan to do any project or business this company is going to put a smile to your face i have also introduced most of my friends to this company and only 2 of my friends told me they have received there loans already one of my friend received a loan of $39,000.00 dollars and the other of my friend received the sum of $65,000.00 dollars so anyone in need of an online loan apply from this company and you will be rest assure, because this company is really helpful and God will continue to use them to help people in need of a loan. If you need an online loan apply from this company and contact them via this means email address karinarolandloancompany@gmail.com or whatsapp only +1(312)8721-592 and also you can contact me via email sharonlogan023@gmail.com for more informatiom, thank you all.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm 15 years old. I was born with HIV my mother passed away because of the HIV infection And I regret why i never met Dr Itua he could have cured my mum for me because as a single mother it was very hard for my mother I came across Dr itua healing words online about how he cure different disease in different races diseases like HIV/Aids Herpes,Parkison,Asthma,Autism,Copd,Epilepsy,Shingles,Cold Sore,Infertility, Chronic Fatigues Syndrome,Fibromyalgia,Love Spell,Prostate Cancer,Lung Cancer,Glaucoma.,psoriasis, Cataracts,Macular degeneration,Cardiovascular disease,Lung disease.Enlarged prostate,Osteoporosis.Alzheimer's disease,psoriasis,
    Dementia.,Tach Disease,Breast Cancer,Blood Cancer,Colo-Rectal Cancer,Love Spell,Chronic Diarrhea,Ataxia,Arthritis,Amyotrophic Lateral Scoliosis,Fibromyalgia,Fluoroquinolone Toxicity
    Syndrome Fibrodysplasia Ossificans ProgresSclerosis,Weak Erection,Breast Enlargment,Penis Enlargment,Hpv,measles, tetanus, whooping cough, tuberculosis, polio and diphtheria)Diabetes Hepatitis even Cancer I was so excited but frighten at same time because I haven't come across such thing article online then I contacted Dr Itua on Mail drituaherbalcenter@gmail.com/ . I also chat with him on what's app +2348149277967 he tells me how it works then I tell him I want to proceed I paid him so swiftly Colorado post office I receive my herbal medicine within 4/5 working days he gave me guild lines to follow and here am I living healthy again can imagine how god use men to manifest his works am I writing in all articles online to spread the god work of Dr Itua Herbal Medicine,He's a Great Man.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Finally got my debts of my neck and i have enough money saved for my Christmas shopping. It all happened as i stumbled into this email address blankatm002@gmail.com initially i was looking to get extra jobs to boost my salary and i found how the blank atm card from this company gives you more than $20,000 all in 1 month. At first i though it was another internet scheme until i saw several reviews of how this blank card from this company has changed the lives of many without hesitation i ordered for the card and in less than 7 days it was delivered to me and the agent showed me how it works and it was even tested its been just 3 weeks and everything seems a lot less stressful this company has really changed my life and standard of living. I would love you on this site to visit blankatm002@gmail.com and get a card today to ease that stress and get good money its so quick.

    ReplyDelete
  5. HOW I GOT MY LOAN FROM THIS GREAT COMPANY

    Hello my dear people, I am Linda McDonald, currently living in Austin Texas, USA. I am a widow at the moment with three kids and i was stuck in a financial situation in April 2018 and i needed to refinance and pay my bills. I tried seeking loans from various loan firms both private and corporate but never with success, and most banks declined my credit ,do not full prey to those hoodlums at there that call them self-money lender they are all scam , all they want is your money and you well not hear from them again they have done it to me twice before I met Mr. David Wilson the most interesting part of it is that my loan was transfer to me within 74hours so I will advise you to contact Mr. David if you are interested in getting loan and you are sure you can pay him back on time you can contact him via email……… (davidwilsonloancompany4@gmail.com) No credit check, no cosigner with just 2% interest rate and better repayment plans and schedule if you must contact any firm with reference to securing a loan without collateral then contact Mr. David Wilson today for your loan .

    They offer all kind of categories of loan they

    Short term loan (5_10years)
    Long term loan (20_40)
    Media term loan (10_20)
    They offer loan like
    Home loan............., Business loan........ Debt loan.......
    Student loan.........., Business startup loan
    Business loan......., Company loan.............. etc
    Email..........( davidwilsonloancompany4@gmail.com)
    When it comes to financial crisis and loan then David Wilson loan financial is the place to go please just tell him I Mrs. Linda McDonald direct you Good Luck.......................

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for sharing your valuable information on this article. This post is helpful to many people.stocks4all is a stock related website which provides all stocks related information like new stocks and shares available in the stock market.
    share market
    tax in India

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nama saya Vania hilman dari Malaysia dan saat ini tinggal di Dubai. Seorang ibu tunggal dengan 2 anak. Saya berdoa dan saya memikirkan kesaksian di internet minggu ini dengan nama PERUSAHAAN RIKA ANDERSON LOAN. Ibu Rika membantu saya dengan $ 60.000 USD.

    PERUSAHAAN PINJAMAN RIKA ANDERSON
    Email kantor, rikaandersonloancompany@gmail.com

    Saya benar-benar membutuhkan mereka, pada awalnya saya tidak pernah mempercayai mereka, tetapi setelah memenuhi permintaan mereka, saya mendapatkan pinjaman saya. Hari ini saya membayar hutang saya dan saya juga bangga dengan apartemen saya sendiri. Ibu dan dua teman saya mengambil keuntungan dari penawaran ini, dan saya juga ingin seluruh negara mengambil keuntungan dari penawaran yang murah hati ini. ini adalah email pribadi saya vaniahilmanaki@gmail.com.

    Penguji: Vania hilman
    Negara Sekarang: Dubai (UEA)
    Jumlah Pinjaman: $ 60.000
    email: vaniahilmanaki@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. My name is Mrs.Aisha Mohamed, am a Citizen Of Qatar.Have you been looking for a loan?Do you need an urgent personal loan or business loan?contact Dr James Eric Finance Home he help me with a loan of $42,000 some days ago after been scammed of $2,800 from a woman claiming to been a loan lender but i thank God today that i got my loan worth $42,000.Feel free to contact the company for a genuine financial service. Email:(financialserviceoffer876@gmail.com) call/whats-App Contact Number +918929509036

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nama saya Siti Maria, dari Indonesia. Saya menghubungi Ny. RIKA ANDERON PINJAMAN DAN PERUSAHAAN INVESTASI BITCOIN untuk bisnis dengan jumlah pinjaman tanpa jaminan $ 10.000. Kemudian saya diberitahu tentang langkah menyetujui jumlah pinjaman yang saya minta, setelah mengambil risiko lagi karena saya sangat ingin mendirikan usaha untuk kejutan terbesar, jumlah pinjaman disetujui dan dikreditkan ke rekening bank saya dalam 7 jam perbankan tanpa ada tekanan mendapatkan pinjaman saya. Saya terkejut karena saya pertama kali menjadi korban penipuan! Jika Anda tertarik untuk mendapatkan jumlah pinjaman tanpa jaminan & Anda berada di negara mana pun, saya akan menyarankan Anda dapat menghubungi RIKA ANDERSON PINJAMAN DAN PERUSAHAAN INVESTASI BITCOIN melalui Email rikaandersonloancompany@gmail.com
    untuk pertanyaan dan penjelasan Whatsapp +1 (323) 689-3663
    Siti: mariasity62@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  10. We have a direct genuine provider for BG/SBLC specifically for lease, at leasing price of 4+2 of face value, Issuance by HSBC London/Hong Kong or any other AA rated Bank in Europe, Middle East or USA.

    Contact : Mr. DARREN C CHENG
    Email: Darrencraig002@gmail.com
    skype : keatcheng2@gmail.com

    Intermediaries/Consultants/Brokers are welcome to bring their clients and are 100% protected. In complete confidence, we will work together for the benefits of all parties involved.

    All inquires to Mr. Darren should include the following minimum information so I can quickly address your needs:

    Complete contact information:
    What exactly do you need?
    How long do you need it for?
    Are you a principal borrower or a broker?

    Contact me for more details.

    Whatsapp: +19733700521

    ReplyDelete
  11. Pada musim pandemi Coronavirus Covid-19 ini, God Bless RIKA ANDERSON Meminjamkan Investasi untuk Membantu Saya Saat Membutuhkan.
    Selamat siang, saya Yanto Yanto dari Jakarta Indonesia Email: yantoyantoal@gmail.com

    Saya memiliki bisnis yang berantakan, sampai saya menemukan perusahaan ini yang membantu saya mendapatkan pinjaman untuk bisnis dan perawatan medis, dan sekarang saya ingin menggunakan media pendek ini untuk memberi selamat kepada perusahaan atas dana cepat dan aman yang mereka pinjamkan kepada saya tanpa ada bentuk keterlambatan atau jaminan.

    Saya dipinjamkan Rp30.000.000 dari perusahaan dengan tingkat bunga sangat rendah 2% untuk menyelamatkan bisnis saya dan banyak lagi. saya pertama kali melihat email mereka di internet, semua orang selalu memberikan kesaksian atas apa yang mereka lakukan, jadi saya segera menghubungi mereka dan mereka semua melakukan segalanya untuk saya tanpa stres dan dana saya dikirim ke akun Maybank dalam waktu 2 jam, saya terkejut dan merasa senang untuk menerima pinjaman saya.

    Sekarang saya sekarang memiliki agen kontrol bisnis standar yang membantu saya, sekarang saya akan memberi saran kepada mereka yang membutuhkan pinjaman mendesak untuk menghubungi mereka sekarang melalui email: rikaandersonloancompany@gmail.com
    Whatsapp + 1323689-3663

    ReplyDelete
  12. kesaksian nyata dan kabar baik !!!

    Nama saya mohammad, saya baru saja menerima pinjaman saya dan telah dipindahkan ke rekening bank saya, beberapa hari yang lalu saya melamar ke Perusahaan Pinjaman Dangote melalui Lady Jane (Ladyjanealice@gmail.com), saya bertanya kepada Lady jane tentang persyaratan Dangote Loan Perusahaan dan wanita jane mengatakan kepada saya bahwa jika saya memiliki semua persyarataan bahwa pinjaman saya akan ditransfer kepada saya tanpa penundaan

    Dan percayalah sekarang karena pinjaman rp11milyar saya dengan tingkat bunga 2% untuk bisnis Tambang Batubara saya baru saja disetujui dan dipindahkan ke akun saya, ini adalah mimpi yang akan datang, saya berjanji kepada Lady jane bahwa saya akan mengatakan kepada dunia apakah ini benar? dan saya akan memberitahu dunia sekarang karena ini benar

    Anda tidak perlu membayar biayaa pendaftaran, biaya lisensi, mematuhi Perusahaan Pinjaman Dangote dan Anda akan mendapatkan pinjaman Anda

    untuk lebih jelasnya hubungi saya via email: mahammadismali234@gmail.comdan hubungi Dangote Loan Company untuk pinjaman Anda sekarang melalui email Dangotegrouploandepartment@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  13. Am Fx Bambang Kartiko Putro dari Surabaya dan saat ini tinggal di Jl otista 82 RT 010 RW 012 Bidara Cina, Jatinegara Jakarta, Indonesia.

    Saya ingin mengucapkan selamat kepada perusahaan Pinjaman Ibu Rika Anderson atas dana cepat dan aman yang mereka berikan kepada saya tanpa jaminan.

    Saya mendapatkan 250 juta (Rp250.000.000) pada tanggal 28 Juli 2020 (28/08/2020) dari ibu Rika Anderson Loan Company dengan bunga 2% untuk menyelamatkan hidup saya, pendidikan anak-anak saya dan bisnis furnitur.

    Saya menyarankan siapapun di Indonesia yang membutuhkan pinjaman untuk segera menghubungi ibu rika. Mereka adalah satu-satunya perusahaan pinjaman yang dapat saya jamin 100% tanpa kekecewaan.

    Kontak melalui email: rikaandersonloancompany@gmail.com
    WA +1 (323) -689-3663
    Twitter: LoanRika
    Facebook: Rika Anderson Alfreda
    Instagram: Rikaandersonloan Tanggal: 28 Juli, 2020
    Email Saya: bambang.kartiko101@gmail.com
    Twitter: @KartikoBambang
    Instagram: bambang.kartiko101

    ReplyDelete
  14. Saya Suryanto dari Indonesia di Kota Palu, saya mencurahkan waktu saya di sini karena janji yang saya berikan kepada LADY ESTHER PATRICK yang kebetulan adalah Tuhan yang mengirim pemberi pinjaman online dan saya berdoa kepada TUHAN untuk dapat melihat posisi saya hari ini.

    Beberapa bulan yang lalu saya melihat komentar yang diposting oleh seorang wanita bernama Nurul Yudianto dan bagaimana dia telah scammed meminta pinjaman online, menurut dia sebelum ALLAH mengarahkannya ke tangan Mrs. ESTHER PATRICK. (ESTHERPATRICK83@GMAIL.COM)

    Saya memutuskan untuk menghubungi NURUL YUDIANTO untuk memastikan apakah itu benar dan untuk membimbing saya tentang cara mendapatkan pinjaman dari LADY ESTHER PATRICK, dia mengatakan kepada saya untuk menghubungi Lady. Saya bersikeras bahwa dia harus memberi tahu saya proses dan kriteria yang dia katakan sangat mudah. dari Mrs. ESTHER, yang perlu saya lakukan adalah menghubunginya, mengisi formulir untuk mengirim pengembalian, mengirim saya scan kartu identitas saya, kemudian mendaftar dengan perusahaan setelah itu saya akan mendapatkan pinjaman saya. . Lalu saya bertanya kepadanya bagaimana Anda mendapatkan pinjaman Anda? Dia menjawab bahwa hanya itu yang dia lakukan, yang sangat mengejutkan.

     Saya menghubungi Mrs ESTHER PATRICK dan saya mengikuti instruksi dengan hati-hati untuk saya, saya memenuhi persyaratan mereka dan pinjaman saya disetujui dengan sukses tetapi sebelum pinjaman dipindahkan ke akun saya, saya diminta membuat janji untuk membagikan kabar baik tentang Mrs. ESTHER PATRICK dan itulah mengapa Anda melihat posting ini hari ini untuk kejutan terbesar saya, saya menerima peringatan Rp350.000.000. jadi saya menyarankan semua orang yang mencari sumber tepercaya untuk mendapatkan pinjaman untuk menghubungi Mrs. ESTHER PATRICK melalui email: (estherpatrick83@gmail.com) untuk mendapatkan pinjaman yang dijamin, Anda juga dapat menghubungi saya di Email saya: (suryantosuryanto524@gmail.com)

    ReplyDelete
  15. Halo semuanya! Bantu saya berterima kasih kepada Bunda Esther

    Saya Widodo saya tinggal di Medan di Indonesia, saya telah mencari pinjaman selama beberapa tahun. Saya 6 kali menjadi korban penipuan dengan pemberi pinjaman palsu yang telah menghancurkan hidup saya, saya memang mencoba bunuh diri karena mereka. Karena saya punya hutang dan tagihan yang harus dibayar. Saya pikir ini sudah berakhir untuk saya, saya tidak lagi memiliki perasaan hidup. Saya hampir menyerah, tidak sampai saya mencari saran dari teman SISKA WIBOWO (siskawibowo71@gmail.com) yang kemudian mengarahkan saya ke pemberi pinjaman yang sangat andal, Ny. ESTHER PATRICK yang meminjamkan pinjaman tanpa jaminan sebesar 150 juta Rupiah dalam waktu kurang dari 24 jam tanpa tekanan atau tekanan pada tingkat bunga lebih rendah dari 2%. (estherpatrick83@gmail.com)

    Saya sangat terkejut ketika saya memeriksa rekening bank saya dan menemukan bahwa jumlah pinjaman yang saya terapkan langsung ditransfer ke rekening bank saya tanpa penundaan atau kekecewaan, karena saya berjanji akan membagikan kabar baik sehingga orang bisa mendapatkan pinjaman dengan mudah tanpa stres . silakan hubungi ibu sekarang estherpatrick83@gmail.com

    Dan saya tahu sebagian besar dari Anda juga telah menjadi korban penipuan, Anda tidak perlu repot lagi karena saya harus menyampaikan kabar baik dan satu-satunya pemberi pinjaman yang dapat Anda percayai, Jadi saya tidak dapat menyimpan ini untuk diri saya sendiri sehingga saya harus mulai dengan membagikan kesaksian tentang mengubah hidup ini bahwa Anda dapat menghubungi saya melalui email (widodocepi@gmail.com) Ny. Esther Patrick Saya selamanya Bersyukur atas Segala yang telah Anda lakukan untuk saya.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hari yang baik untuk semua warga negara Indonesia, nama saya Nurul Yudianto, tolong, saya ingin berbagi kesaksian hidup saya yang sebenarnya di sini di platform ini sehingga semua warga negara Indonesia berhati-hati dengan pemberi pinjaman pinjaman di internet

    Setelah beberapa waktu berusaha mendapatkan pinjaman dari lembaga keuangan, dan terus ditolak, saya memutuskan untuk mengajukan pinjaman secara online tetapi saya curang dan kehilangan Rp18,7 juta, kepada seorang wanita di saudi arabia dan Nigeria.

    Saya menjadi sangat putus asa dalam mendapatkan pinjaman, jadi saya berdiskusi dengan teman saya Nyonya Rika Nadia (rikanadia6@gmail.com) yang kemudian memperkenalkan saya kepada Lady Esther, manajer Cabang dari Access Loan Firm, sehingga teman saya meminta saya untuk mendaftar dari LADY ESTHER, jadi saya Menjerit dituangkan dan dihubungi LADY ESTHER. melalui email: (estherpatrick83@gmail.com)

    Saya mengajukan pinjaman sebesar Rp250 juta dengan suku bunga 2%, sehingga pinjaman disetujui dengan mudah tanpa tekanan dan semua persiapan dilakukan dengan transfer kredit, karena tidak memerlukan jaminan dan jaminan untuk pengalihan pinjaman, saya diberitahu untuk mendapatkan sertifikat perjanjian lisensi untuk mentransfer kredit saya dan dalam waktu kurang dari satu setengah jam uang pinjaman telah dimasukkan ke dalam rekening bank saya.

    Saya pikir itu adalah lelucon sampai saya menerima panggilan dari bank saya bahwa akun saya telah dikreditkan dengan jumlah Rp250 juta. Saya sangat senang bahwa akhirnya Tuhan telah menjawab doa-doa saya dengan buku pinjaman dengan pinjaman asli saya, yang telah memberi saya keinginan hati saya.

    Semoga Tuhan memberkati LADY ESTHER untuk mewujudkan kehidupan yang adil bagi saya, jadi saya menyarankan siapa pun yang tertarik untuk mendapatkan pinjaman untuk menghubungi Mrs. LADY ESTHER melalui email: (estherpatrick83@gmail.com) atas pinjaman Anda

    Akhirnya saya ingin berterima kasih kepada Anda semua karena meluangkan waktu untuk membaca kesaksian hidup saya yang sebenarnya tentang kesuksesan saya dan saya berdoa kepada Tuhan untuk melakukan kehendak-Nya dalam hidup Anda. Anda dapat menghubungi saya untuk informasi lebih lanjut melalui email saya: (nurulyudianto2@gmail.com) Salam

    ReplyDelete
  17. Halo semuanya, Nama saya Siska wibowo saya tinggal di Surabaya di Indonesia, saya seorang mahasiswa, saya ingin menggunakan kesempatan ini untuk mengingatkan semua pencari pinjaman untuk sangat berhati-hati karena ada banyak perusahaan pinjaman penipuan dan kejahatan di sini di internet , Sampai saya melihat posting Bapak Suryanto tentang Nyonya Esther Patrick dan saya menghubunginya melalui email: (estherpatrick83@gmail.com)

    Beberapa bulan yang lalu, saya putus asa untuk membantu biaya sekolah dan proyek saya tetapi tidak ada yang membantu dan ayah saya hanya dapat memperbaiki beberapa hal yang bahkan tidak cukup, jadi saya mencari pinjaman online tetapi scammed.

    Saya hampir tidak menyerah sampai saya mencari saran dari teman saya Pak Suryanto memanggil saya pemberi pinjaman yang sangat andal yang meminjamkan dengan pinjaman tanpa jaminan sebesar Rp200.000.000 dalam waktu kurang dari 24 jam tanpa tekanan atau tekanan dengan tingkat bunga rendah 2 %. Saya sangat terkejut ketika saya memeriksa rekening bank saya dan menemukan bahwa nomor saya diterapkan langsung ditransfer ke rekening bank saya tanpa penundaan atau kekecewaan, segera saya menghubungi ibu melalui (estherpatrick83@gmail.com)

    Dan juga saya diberi pilihan apakah saya ingin cek kertas dikirim kepada saya melalui jasa kurir, tetapi saya mengatakan kepada mereka untuk mentransfer uang ke rekening bank saya, karena saya berjanji bahwa saya akan membagikan kabar baik sehingga orang bisa mendapatkan pinjaman mudah tanpa stres atau penundaan.

    Yakin dan yakin bahwa ini asli karena saya memiliki semua bukti pemrosesan pinjaman ini termasuk kartu ID, dokumen perjanjian pinjaman, dan semua dokumen. Saya sangat mempercayai Madam ESTHER PATRICK dengan penghargaan dan kepercayaan perusahaan yang sepenuh hati karena dia benar-benar telah membantu hidup saya membayar proyek saya. Anda sangat beruntung memiliki kesempatan untuk membaca kesaksian ini hari ini. Jadi, jika Anda membutuhkan pinjaman, silakan hubungi Madam melalui email: (estherpatrick83@gmail.com)

    Anda juga dapat menghubungi saya melalui email saya di (siskawibowo71@gmail.com) jika Anda merasa kesulitan atau menginginkan prosedur untuk mendapatkan pinjaman

    Sekarang, yang saya lakukan adalah mencoba untuk memenuhi pembayaran pinjaman bulanan yang saya kirim langsung ke rekening bulanan Nyonya seperti yang diarahkan. Tuhan akan memberkati Nyonya ESTHER PATRICK untuk Segalanya. Saya bersyukur

    ReplyDelete
  18. Halo semuanya! Bantu saya berterima kasih kepada Bunda Esther

    Saya Widodo saya tinggal di Medan di Indonesia, saya telah mencari pinjaman selama beberapa tahun. Saya 6 kali menjadi korban penipuan dengan pemberi pinjaman palsu yang telah menghancurkan hidup saya, saya memang mencoba bunuh diri karena mereka. Karena saya punya hutang dan tagihan yang harus dibayar. Saya pikir ini sudah berakhir untuk saya, saya tidak lagi memiliki perasaan hidup. Saya hampir menyerah, tidak sampai saya mencari saran dari teman SISKA WIBOWO (siskawibowo71@gmail.com) yang kemudian mengarahkan saya ke pemberi pinjaman yang sangat andal, Ny. ESTHER PATRICK yang meminjamkan pinjaman tanpa jaminan sebesar 150 juta Rupiah dalam waktu kurang dari 24 jam tanpa tekanan atau tekanan pada tingkat bunga lebih rendah dari 2%. (estherpatrick83@gmail.com)

    Saya sangat terkejut ketika saya memeriksa rekening bank saya dan menemukan bahwa jumlah pinjaman yang saya terapkan langsung ditransfer ke rekening bank saya tanpa penundaan atau kekecewaan, karena saya berjanji akan membagikan kabar baik sehingga orang bisa mendapatkan pinjaman dengan mudah tanpa stres . silakan hubungi ibu sekarang estherpatrick83@gmail.com

    Dan saya tahu sebagian besar dari Anda juga telah menjadi korban penipuan, Anda tidak perlu repot lagi karena saya harus menyampaikan kabar baik dan satu-satunya pemberi pinjaman yang dapat Anda percayai, Jadi saya tidak dapat menyimpan ini untuk diri saya sendiri sehingga saya harus mulai dengan membagikan kesaksian tentang mengubah hidup ini bahwa Anda dapat menghubungi saya melalui email (widodocepi@gmail.com) Ny. Esther Patrick Saya selamanya Bersyukur atas Segala yang telah Anda lakukan untuk saya.

    ReplyDelete